Why psychoanalysis is a science

Research output: Contribution to journalLiterature review

Abstract

In his recent book, Guénaël Visentini valiantly argues that the status of truth and knowledge in science must be reevaluated if psychoanalysis is ever to approach the sciences. Sigmund Freud’s work not only attests to the subjective division of humans but reflects on the production of analytic knowledge, one which obliges the deconstruction of the scientific ideal. Visentini affirms that after Freud, one can no longer speak of science but rather of the sciences, each with its measures and methods and each with its object of research. Throughout his lifetime of work, Freud created an epistemology the “analytic epistemology of psychoanalysis.” Visentini uses the term analytic epistemology because a philosophic epistemology of psychoanalysis already exists in the reflections of Adolf Grünbaum and Karl Popper. Psychoanalysis would thus be the science of psychical functioning, one still lacking mathematical formalization, but a science nonetheless.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)985-987
Number of pages3
JournalCritical Inquiry
Volume42
Issue number4
Publication statusPublished - 15 Jan 2016

Cite this

Hafner, David. / Why psychoanalysis is a science. In: Critical Inquiry. 2016 ; Vol. 42, No. 4. pp. 985-987.
@article{6079c850beba46c6bd98e9e2f426f193,
title = "Why psychoanalysis is a science",
abstract = "In his recent book, Gu{\'e}na{\"e}l Visentini valiantly argues that the status of truth and knowledge in science must be reevaluated if psychoanalysis is ever to approach the sciences. Sigmund Freud’s work not only attests to the subjective division of humans but reflects on the production of analytic knowledge, one which obliges the deconstruction of the scientific ideal. Visentini affirms that after Freud, one can no longer speak of science but rather of the sciences, each with its measures and methods and each with its object of research. Throughout his lifetime of work, Freud created an epistemology the “analytic epistemology of psychoanalysis.” Visentini uses the term analytic epistemology because a philosophic epistemology of psychoanalysis already exists in the reflections of Adolf Grünbaum and Karl Popper. Psychoanalysis would thus be the science of psychical functioning, one still lacking mathematical formalization, but a science nonetheless.",
author = "David Hafner",
year = "2016",
month = "1",
day = "15",
language = "English",
volume = "42",
pages = "985--987",
journal = "Critical Inquiry",
issn = "0093-1896",
publisher = "University of Chicago",
number = "4",

}

Hafner, D 2016, 'Why psychoanalysis is a science', Critical Inquiry, vol. 42, no. 4, pp. 985-987.

Why psychoanalysis is a science. / Hafner, David.

In: Critical Inquiry, Vol. 42, No. 4, 15.01.2016, p. 985-987.

Research output: Contribution to journalLiterature review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Why psychoanalysis is a science

AU - Hafner, David

PY - 2016/1/15

Y1 - 2016/1/15

N2 - In his recent book, Guénaël Visentini valiantly argues that the status of truth and knowledge in science must be reevaluated if psychoanalysis is ever to approach the sciences. Sigmund Freud’s work not only attests to the subjective division of humans but reflects on the production of analytic knowledge, one which obliges the deconstruction of the scientific ideal. Visentini affirms that after Freud, one can no longer speak of science but rather of the sciences, each with its measures and methods and each with its object of research. Throughout his lifetime of work, Freud created an epistemology the “analytic epistemology of psychoanalysis.” Visentini uses the term analytic epistemology because a philosophic epistemology of psychoanalysis already exists in the reflections of Adolf Grünbaum and Karl Popper. Psychoanalysis would thus be the science of psychical functioning, one still lacking mathematical formalization, but a science nonetheless.

AB - In his recent book, Guénaël Visentini valiantly argues that the status of truth and knowledge in science must be reevaluated if psychoanalysis is ever to approach the sciences. Sigmund Freud’s work not only attests to the subjective division of humans but reflects on the production of analytic knowledge, one which obliges the deconstruction of the scientific ideal. Visentini affirms that after Freud, one can no longer speak of science but rather of the sciences, each with its measures and methods and each with its object of research. Throughout his lifetime of work, Freud created an epistemology the “analytic epistemology of psychoanalysis.” Visentini uses the term analytic epistemology because a philosophic epistemology of psychoanalysis already exists in the reflections of Adolf Grünbaum and Karl Popper. Psychoanalysis would thus be the science of psychical functioning, one still lacking mathematical formalization, but a science nonetheless.

M3 - Literature review

VL - 42

SP - 985

EP - 987

JO - Critical Inquiry

JF - Critical Inquiry

SN - 0093-1896

IS - 4

ER -