Rol of creative discussion in the learning of critical reading of scientific articles

Héctor Cobos-Aguilar, Leonardo Viniegra-Velázquez, Patricia Pérez-Cortés

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective. To compare two active educational strategies on critical reading (two and three stages) for research learning in medical students. Material and methods. Four groups were conformed in a quasi-experimental design. The medical student group, related to three stages (critical reading guide resolution, creative discussion, group discussion) g1, n = 9 with school marks > 90 and g2, n = 19 with a < 90, respectively. The two-stage groups (guide resolution and group discussion) were conformed by pre-graduate interns, g3, n = 17 and g4, n = 12, who attended social security general hospitals. A validated and consistent survey with 144 items was applied to the four groups before and after educational strategies. Critical reading with its subcomponents: interpretation, judgment and proposal were evaluated with 47, 49 and 48 items, respectively. The case control studies, cohort studies, diagnostic test and clinical trial designs were evaluated. Non-parametric significance tests were performed to compare the groups and their results. A bias calculation was performed for each group. Results. The highest median was obtained by the three-stage groups (g1 and g2) and so were the medians in interpretation, judgment and proposal. The several research design results were higher in the same groups. Conclusions. An active educational strategy with three stages is superior to another with two stages in medical students. It is advisable to perform these activities in goal of better learning in our students.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)268-278
Number of pages11
JournalRevista de Investigacion Clinica
Publication statusPublished - 1 May 2011

Fingerprint

Medical Students
Reading
Learning
Research Design
Social Security
Routine Diagnostic Tests
General Hospitals
Case-Control Studies
Cohort Studies
Clinical Trials
Students
Research

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Cobos-Aguilar, H., Viniegra-Velázquez, L., & Pérez-Cortés, P. (2011). Rol of creative discussion in the learning of critical reading of scientific articles. Revista de Investigacion Clinica, 268-278.
Cobos-Aguilar, Héctor ; Viniegra-Velázquez, Leonardo ; Pérez-Cortés, Patricia. / Rol of creative discussion in the learning of critical reading of scientific articles. In: Revista de Investigacion Clinica. 2011 ; pp. 268-278.
@article{016817a3f6b6406485e3bf620978764c,
title = "Rol of creative discussion in the learning of critical reading of scientific articles",
abstract = "Objective. To compare two active educational strategies on critical reading (two and three stages) for research learning in medical students. Material and methods. Four groups were conformed in a quasi-experimental design. The medical student group, related to three stages (critical reading guide resolution, creative discussion, group discussion) g1, n = 9 with school marks > 90 and g2, n = 19 with a < 90, respectively. The two-stage groups (guide resolution and group discussion) were conformed by pre-graduate interns, g3, n = 17 and g4, n = 12, who attended social security general hospitals. A validated and consistent survey with 144 items was applied to the four groups before and after educational strategies. Critical reading with its subcomponents: interpretation, judgment and proposal were evaluated with 47, 49 and 48 items, respectively. The case control studies, cohort studies, diagnostic test and clinical trial designs were evaluated. Non-parametric significance tests were performed to compare the groups and their results. A bias calculation was performed for each group. Results. The highest median was obtained by the three-stage groups (g1 and g2) and so were the medians in interpretation, judgment and proposal. The several research design results were higher in the same groups. Conclusions. An active educational strategy with three stages is superior to another with two stages in medical students. It is advisable to perform these activities in goal of better learning in our students.",
author = "H{\'e}ctor Cobos-Aguilar and Leonardo Viniegra-Vel{\'a}zquez and Patricia P{\'e}rez-Cort{\'e}s",
year = "2011",
month = "5",
day = "1",
language = "English",
pages = "268--278",
journal = "Revista de Investigacion Clinica",
issn = "0034-8376",
publisher = "Instituto Nacional de la Nutricion Salvador Zubiran",

}

Cobos-Aguilar, H, Viniegra-Velázquez, L & Pérez-Cortés, P 2011, 'Rol of creative discussion in the learning of critical reading of scientific articles', Revista de Investigacion Clinica, pp. 268-278.

Rol of creative discussion in the learning of critical reading of scientific articles. / Cobos-Aguilar, Héctor; Viniegra-Velázquez, Leonardo; Pérez-Cortés, Patricia.

In: Revista de Investigacion Clinica, 01.05.2011, p. 268-278.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Rol of creative discussion in the learning of critical reading of scientific articles

AU - Cobos-Aguilar, Héctor

AU - Viniegra-Velázquez, Leonardo

AU - Pérez-Cortés, Patricia

PY - 2011/5/1

Y1 - 2011/5/1

N2 - Objective. To compare two active educational strategies on critical reading (two and three stages) for research learning in medical students. Material and methods. Four groups were conformed in a quasi-experimental design. The medical student group, related to three stages (critical reading guide resolution, creative discussion, group discussion) g1, n = 9 with school marks > 90 and g2, n = 19 with a < 90, respectively. The two-stage groups (guide resolution and group discussion) were conformed by pre-graduate interns, g3, n = 17 and g4, n = 12, who attended social security general hospitals. A validated and consistent survey with 144 items was applied to the four groups before and after educational strategies. Critical reading with its subcomponents: interpretation, judgment and proposal were evaluated with 47, 49 and 48 items, respectively. The case control studies, cohort studies, diagnostic test and clinical trial designs were evaluated. Non-parametric significance tests were performed to compare the groups and their results. A bias calculation was performed for each group. Results. The highest median was obtained by the three-stage groups (g1 and g2) and so were the medians in interpretation, judgment and proposal. The several research design results were higher in the same groups. Conclusions. An active educational strategy with three stages is superior to another with two stages in medical students. It is advisable to perform these activities in goal of better learning in our students.

AB - Objective. To compare two active educational strategies on critical reading (two and three stages) for research learning in medical students. Material and methods. Four groups were conformed in a quasi-experimental design. The medical student group, related to three stages (critical reading guide resolution, creative discussion, group discussion) g1, n = 9 with school marks > 90 and g2, n = 19 with a < 90, respectively. The two-stage groups (guide resolution and group discussion) were conformed by pre-graduate interns, g3, n = 17 and g4, n = 12, who attended social security general hospitals. A validated and consistent survey with 144 items was applied to the four groups before and after educational strategies. Critical reading with its subcomponents: interpretation, judgment and proposal were evaluated with 47, 49 and 48 items, respectively. The case control studies, cohort studies, diagnostic test and clinical trial designs were evaluated. Non-parametric significance tests were performed to compare the groups and their results. A bias calculation was performed for each group. Results. The highest median was obtained by the three-stage groups (g1 and g2) and so were the medians in interpretation, judgment and proposal. The several research design results were higher in the same groups. Conclusions. An active educational strategy with three stages is superior to another with two stages in medical students. It is advisable to perform these activities in goal of better learning in our students.

M3 - Article

SP - 268

EP - 278

JO - Revista de Investigacion Clinica

JF - Revista de Investigacion Clinica

SN - 0034-8376

ER -

Cobos-Aguilar H, Viniegra-Velázquez L, Pérez-Cortés P. Rol of creative discussion in the learning of critical reading of scientific articles. Revista de Investigacion Clinica. 2011 May 1;268-278.