Proposed maturity assessment framework for a research field

Heather Keathley, Fernando Gonzalez Aleu, Pablo Felipe Cárdenas Orlandini, Eileen Van Aken, Fernando Deschamps, Luciana Rosa Leite

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In recent years, an increasing number of papers have been published that analyze the literature of a research field to determine its main contributors, topics, and perspectives. These works apply approaches such as systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis to describe various characteristics of a given field which are considered in the development of future research. One of these characteristics, the notion of research field maturity, has been mentioned in many works but has not yet been formalized resulting in a lack of consensus concerning the definition and analysis techniques. The inclusion of a maturity assessment could lend new insights to how to position future research in order to maximize its contribution and to legitimize the literature and the works created from it. This paper defines the maturity of a research field and discusses its assessment based on three main criteria: authorship (who the primary authors are and the relationships between them), breadth of methods (the variety of research methods used), and academic/practitioner relationship (to what extent the results of research are successfully being applied). A framework using these criteria for the maturity assessment of a research field is proposed. Part of this maturity framework is pilot tested using the enterprise engineering research field.
Original languageEnglish
Pages764-773
Number of pages10
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2013
Externally publishedYes
EventIIE Annual Conference and Expo 2013 -
Duration: 1 Jan 2013 → …

Conference

ConferenceIIE Annual Conference and Expo 2013
Period1/1/13 → …

Fingerprint

Engineering research
Industry

Cite this

Keathley, H., Gonzalez Aleu, F., Cárdenas Orlandini, P. F., Van Aken, E., Deschamps, F., & Rosa Leite, L. (2013). Proposed maturity assessment framework for a research field. 764-773. Paper presented at IIE Annual Conference and Expo 2013, .
Keathley, Heather ; Gonzalez Aleu, Fernando ; Cárdenas Orlandini, Pablo Felipe ; Van Aken, Eileen ; Deschamps, Fernando ; Rosa Leite, Luciana. / Proposed maturity assessment framework for a research field. Paper presented at IIE Annual Conference and Expo 2013, .10 p.
@conference{e7d5dafddc6f4edca7f97ad589d64fec,
title = "Proposed maturity assessment framework for a research field",
abstract = "In recent years, an increasing number of papers have been published that analyze the literature of a research field to determine its main contributors, topics, and perspectives. These works apply approaches such as systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis to describe various characteristics of a given field which are considered in the development of future research. One of these characteristics, the notion of research field maturity, has been mentioned in many works but has not yet been formalized resulting in a lack of consensus concerning the definition and analysis techniques. The inclusion of a maturity assessment could lend new insights to how to position future research in order to maximize its contribution and to legitimize the literature and the works created from it. This paper defines the maturity of a research field and discusses its assessment based on three main criteria: authorship (who the primary authors are and the relationships between them), breadth of methods (the variety of research methods used), and academic/practitioner relationship (to what extent the results of research are successfully being applied). A framework using these criteria for the maturity assessment of a research field is proposed. Part of this maturity framework is pilot tested using the enterprise engineering research field.",
author = "Heather Keathley and {Gonzalez Aleu}, Fernando and {C{\'a}rdenas Orlandini}, {Pablo Felipe} and {Van Aken}, Eileen and Fernando Deschamps and {Rosa Leite}, Luciana",
year = "2013",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English",
pages = "764--773",
note = "IIE Annual Conference and Expo 2013 ; Conference date: 01-01-2013",

}

Keathley, H, Gonzalez Aleu, F, Cárdenas Orlandini, PF, Van Aken, E, Deschamps, F & Rosa Leite, L 2013, 'Proposed maturity assessment framework for a research field' Paper presented at IIE Annual Conference and Expo 2013, 1/1/13, pp. 764-773.

Proposed maturity assessment framework for a research field. / Keathley, Heather; Gonzalez Aleu, Fernando; Cárdenas Orlandini, Pablo Felipe; Van Aken, Eileen; Deschamps, Fernando; Rosa Leite, Luciana.

2013. 764-773 Paper presented at IIE Annual Conference and Expo 2013, .

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Proposed maturity assessment framework for a research field

AU - Keathley, Heather

AU - Gonzalez Aleu, Fernando

AU - Cárdenas Orlandini, Pablo Felipe

AU - Van Aken, Eileen

AU - Deschamps, Fernando

AU - Rosa Leite, Luciana

PY - 2013/1/1

Y1 - 2013/1/1

N2 - In recent years, an increasing number of papers have been published that analyze the literature of a research field to determine its main contributors, topics, and perspectives. These works apply approaches such as systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis to describe various characteristics of a given field which are considered in the development of future research. One of these characteristics, the notion of research field maturity, has been mentioned in many works but has not yet been formalized resulting in a lack of consensus concerning the definition and analysis techniques. The inclusion of a maturity assessment could lend new insights to how to position future research in order to maximize its contribution and to legitimize the literature and the works created from it. This paper defines the maturity of a research field and discusses its assessment based on three main criteria: authorship (who the primary authors are and the relationships between them), breadth of methods (the variety of research methods used), and academic/practitioner relationship (to what extent the results of research are successfully being applied). A framework using these criteria for the maturity assessment of a research field is proposed. Part of this maturity framework is pilot tested using the enterprise engineering research field.

AB - In recent years, an increasing number of papers have been published that analyze the literature of a research field to determine its main contributors, topics, and perspectives. These works apply approaches such as systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis to describe various characteristics of a given field which are considered in the development of future research. One of these characteristics, the notion of research field maturity, has been mentioned in many works but has not yet been formalized resulting in a lack of consensus concerning the definition and analysis techniques. The inclusion of a maturity assessment could lend new insights to how to position future research in order to maximize its contribution and to legitimize the literature and the works created from it. This paper defines the maturity of a research field and discusses its assessment based on three main criteria: authorship (who the primary authors are and the relationships between them), breadth of methods (the variety of research methods used), and academic/practitioner relationship (to what extent the results of research are successfully being applied). A framework using these criteria for the maturity assessment of a research field is proposed. Part of this maturity framework is pilot tested using the enterprise engineering research field.

M3 - Paper

SP - 764

EP - 773

ER -

Keathley H, Gonzalez Aleu F, Cárdenas Orlandini PF, Van Aken E, Deschamps F, Rosa Leite L. Proposed maturity assessment framework for a research field. 2013. Paper presented at IIE Annual Conference and Expo 2013, .