Maturity assessment of performance measurement implementation success factor literature

Heather Keathley, Fernando Gonzalez Aleu, Pablo Cárdenas Orlandini, Eileen Van Aken, Fernando Deschamps, Luciana Rosa Leite

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Recent trends in academic research have led to an increase in the publication of papers that aim to evaluate the literature of a specific research field in order to identify both research trends and appropriate topics for future research. As literature reviews become more methodological and standardized, approaches such as systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis are becoming more popular. One aspect of literature characterization that is often mentioned but has not yet been formalized is the notion of research field maturity; essentially, whether the research area is new and highly theoretical or has been more developed with convergence on best practices. The information gained from this type of analysis can help to further characterize the literature and identify future research areas as well as work to legitimize the literature and the conclusions drawn from it. This paper extends previous work which defined maturity and presented a framework for assessment based on three criteria: authorship, breadth of methods, and academic/practitioner relationship. This study applies the framework to the final paper set from a previous systematic literature review and the maturity of this field is assessed to be moderately mature with some criteria appearing stronger than others. In addition, the usefulness of the framework and future work are discussed.
Original languageEnglish
Pages577-587
Number of pages11
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2013
Externally publishedYes
EventInternational Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management 2013, ASEM 2013 -
Duration: 1 Jan 2013 → …

Conference

ConferenceInternational Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management 2013, ASEM 2013
Period1/1/13 → …

Fingerprint

Maturity
Success factors
Performance measurement
Literature review
Field research
Bibliometric analysis
Research trends
Authorship
Academic research
Usefulness
Best practice

Cite this

Keathley, H., Aleu, F. G., Orlandini, P. C., Van Aken, E., Deschamps, F., & Leite, L. R. (2013). Maturity assessment of performance measurement implementation success factor literature. 577-587. Paper presented at International Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management 2013, ASEM 2013, .
Keathley, Heather ; Aleu, Fernando Gonzalez ; Orlandini, Pablo Cárdenas ; Van Aken, Eileen ; Deschamps, Fernando ; Leite, Luciana Rosa. / Maturity assessment of performance measurement implementation success factor literature. Paper presented at International Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management 2013, ASEM 2013, .11 p.
@conference{7a9bfcf8ebd84404bb98846272c41744,
title = "Maturity assessment of performance measurement implementation success factor literature",
abstract = "Recent trends in academic research have led to an increase in the publication of papers that aim to evaluate the literature of a specific research field in order to identify both research trends and appropriate topics for future research. As literature reviews become more methodological and standardized, approaches such as systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis are becoming more popular. One aspect of literature characterization that is often mentioned but has not yet been formalized is the notion of research field maturity; essentially, whether the research area is new and highly theoretical or has been more developed with convergence on best practices. The information gained from this type of analysis can help to further characterize the literature and identify future research areas as well as work to legitimize the literature and the conclusions drawn from it. This paper extends previous work which defined maturity and presented a framework for assessment based on three criteria: authorship, breadth of methods, and academic/practitioner relationship. This study applies the framework to the final paper set from a previous systematic literature review and the maturity of this field is assessed to be moderately mature with some criteria appearing stronger than others. In addition, the usefulness of the framework and future work are discussed.",
author = "Heather Keathley and Aleu, {Fernando Gonzalez} and Orlandini, {Pablo C{\'a}rdenas} and {Van Aken}, Eileen and Fernando Deschamps and Leite, {Luciana Rosa}",
year = "2013",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English",
pages = "577--587",
note = "International Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management 2013, ASEM 2013 ; Conference date: 01-01-2013",

}

Keathley, H, Aleu, FG, Orlandini, PC, Van Aken, E, Deschamps, F & Leite, LR 2013, 'Maturity assessment of performance measurement implementation success factor literature' Paper presented at International Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management 2013, ASEM 2013, 1/1/13, pp. 577-587.

Maturity assessment of performance measurement implementation success factor literature. / Keathley, Heather; Aleu, Fernando Gonzalez; Orlandini, Pablo Cárdenas; Van Aken, Eileen; Deschamps, Fernando; Leite, Luciana Rosa.

2013. 577-587 Paper presented at International Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management 2013, ASEM 2013, .

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Maturity assessment of performance measurement implementation success factor literature

AU - Keathley, Heather

AU - Aleu, Fernando Gonzalez

AU - Orlandini, Pablo Cárdenas

AU - Van Aken, Eileen

AU - Deschamps, Fernando

AU - Leite, Luciana Rosa

PY - 2013/1/1

Y1 - 2013/1/1

N2 - Recent trends in academic research have led to an increase in the publication of papers that aim to evaluate the literature of a specific research field in order to identify both research trends and appropriate topics for future research. As literature reviews become more methodological and standardized, approaches such as systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis are becoming more popular. One aspect of literature characterization that is often mentioned but has not yet been formalized is the notion of research field maturity; essentially, whether the research area is new and highly theoretical or has been more developed with convergence on best practices. The information gained from this type of analysis can help to further characterize the literature and identify future research areas as well as work to legitimize the literature and the conclusions drawn from it. This paper extends previous work which defined maturity and presented a framework for assessment based on three criteria: authorship, breadth of methods, and academic/practitioner relationship. This study applies the framework to the final paper set from a previous systematic literature review and the maturity of this field is assessed to be moderately mature with some criteria appearing stronger than others. In addition, the usefulness of the framework and future work are discussed.

AB - Recent trends in academic research have led to an increase in the publication of papers that aim to evaluate the literature of a specific research field in order to identify both research trends and appropriate topics for future research. As literature reviews become more methodological and standardized, approaches such as systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis are becoming more popular. One aspect of literature characterization that is often mentioned but has not yet been formalized is the notion of research field maturity; essentially, whether the research area is new and highly theoretical or has been more developed with convergence on best practices. The information gained from this type of analysis can help to further characterize the literature and identify future research areas as well as work to legitimize the literature and the conclusions drawn from it. This paper extends previous work which defined maturity and presented a framework for assessment based on three criteria: authorship, breadth of methods, and academic/practitioner relationship. This study applies the framework to the final paper set from a previous systematic literature review and the maturity of this field is assessed to be moderately mature with some criteria appearing stronger than others. In addition, the usefulness of the framework and future work are discussed.

M3 - Paper

SP - 577

EP - 587

ER -

Keathley H, Aleu FG, Orlandini PC, Van Aken E, Deschamps F, Leite LR. Maturity assessment of performance measurement implementation success factor literature. 2013. Paper presented at International Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management 2013, ASEM 2013, .